The Ideal Heating for Room Climate and Health

Because humans do not have the ability to with­stand the natural elements, we wear clothes and build shelters. In cold climates we heat those shel­ters. Many systems have been invented for heating the home, but not all systems are created equal. After examining the criteria that create health and a comfortable indoor climate, I chose to focus my career on the creation of Kachelofens, or masonry oven heating systems, because of their superior quality and performance. A Kachelofen-Masonry Heater is an individually designed, technically cal­culated, thermal mass wood-fired heating system.

From a Building Biology point of view, let us ex­amine the criteria for creating a comfortable and healthy indoor environment and discover why the Masonry Heater is one of the best heating systems for meeting these criteria.

1. Type of Heat: A heating system should create radiant heat, like the heat from the sun. With a radiant heat source, the room air tempera­ture can stay relatively low at 18 to 20 degrees Celsius (64 to 68 degrees Fahrenheit) and still be comfortably warm because, unlike the con­vection heat from a forced-air source, radiant

heat warms walls, floors, and ceilings as well as furniture and bodies and not the room air. Therefore the room air is barely moving, or moving only at low speed, which means no electrostatic charge, no dust circulation, and no transfer of odors. Kachelofens-Masonry Heaters release about 60 to 70 percent radiant heat and only about 30 to 40 percent convec­tion heat, an output not attainable with any other heating system.

2. Temperature: The quality of a heating system should not be measured by high room-air temperatures but rather by low differences be­tween the room-air temperature and the tem­peratures of the walls, ceilings, and floors, as shown in the sketches.

Kachelofen-Masonry Heater

vacuums should have true HEPA filtra­tion or be exhausted to the outside. No chemicals shall be used in the process.

• Prior to occupancy, the air distribution system shall be tested for leakage by a qualified third party or in the presence of the owner or architect. Any leakage greater than 3 percent shall be remedied by the contractor at no additional expense to the owner.

Once the ducts are in place, a regular main­tenance program is essential to maintaining a healthy system. Identify a professional main­tenance company that uses high-powered duct cleaning equipment. Avoid the use of chemical cleaners.

Masonry Ovens

From a Building Biology perspective, the ideal heating system would have the following fea­tures:

• It would be a radiant source.

• It would not rob the air of negative ions. (When air is forced through metal duct­work, negative ions will be attracted to the ductwork and room air ions will be de­pleted.)

• The appliance would not be hot enough to fry dust.

• It would not create “temperature monot­ony” (having all rooms the same temper­ature, which Building Biology considers unhealthy) or drafts.

discharge are major irritants to mucous mem­branes and cause many chronic illnesses and allergies. Since the surface temperatures of Kachelofens-Masonry Heaters are below no degrees Celsius, dust circulation, combustion of dust, and electric discharge of the room air do not occur.

4. Humidity: Room air should have a relative humidity of approximately 50 to 60 percent, which can be achieved only by radiant heat. Heating systems operating with mainly con­vection heat will bring the relative humidity in a room down to 30 percent. To compensate, some forced-air systems have built-in humid­ifiers, but these can cause condensation and mold buildup in the ductwork.

5. Temperature gradients: Convection heat cre­ates horizontal layers of air in a room, with temperature differences up to 10 degrees Cel­sius from floor to ceiling, resulting in hot heads and cold feet. The temperature differences in rooms with radiant heat from Kachelofens — Masonry Heaters are only 1 to 2 degrees Cel­sius, meaning the room is evenly heated.

6. Electromagnetic fields: Heating systems with mainly convection heat (electric and hot — water baseboard heaters and hot-water radia­tors) create electromagnetic fields that cause electric stress. Permanent electric stress can be the cause of illnesses. Kachelofens-Masonry Heaters do not cause electromagnetic fields or electric stress.

7. Ionization of room air: Wood fire creates a neg­ative ionization of the room air. Why is this important? An ion has either a positive or a negative charge. We have positive and nega­tive ions in our body, but when we run, walk, work, or just generally move we lose negative ions. We are left with positive ions, or a posi­tive charge in our body, and we need to find a source of negative ions to balance our positive charge. Wood fire is one of the best sources to recharge our body with negative ions.

8. Noise:The only noise created by Kachelofens — Masonry Heaters is the cozy crackling of the wood fire.

9. Environmental impact: Of all heating systems, the Kachelofen-Masonry Heater has the low­est overall impact on our environment, from production of the building materials to instal­lation, to the amount of fuel required and pol­lution generated, to disposal after a lifetime of at least 80 years. Unlike a woodstove, which in cold climates must burn wood constantly to heat a home, a masonry oven is fired only for a short duration, fully burning the combus­tion gases and storing heat in its mass walls. It therefore uses far less wood than a woodstove and creates very little pollution in the form of smoke.

A study of Kachelofens-Masonry Heaters con­ducted by the Technical University of Vienna showed the following:

• There would be minimal byproducts of combustion.

Wood heat distributed through a masonry oven can fulfill these criteria. The masonry oven, not to be confused with other types of “fireplaces” or woodburning stoves, is de­signed to burn wood so that the gases are completely combusted. The generated heat circulates through multiple chambers within the oven and is distributed into the ovens mas­sive walls before the relatively clean and cool

Criteria	Ideal	Kachelofen
Room Temperature	18 to 20° C	18 to 20° C
Temperature gradient	1 to 2° C	2 to 4° C
Wall temperature	20 to 22° C	18 to 20° C
Humidity	40 to 60 %	40 to 60 %
Air movement	<0.1 m/s	<0.1 m/s
Dust circulation	no	low
Odors	no	low and pleasant
Ionization	natural	natural
Noise	no/pleasant	no/pleasant
Design	individual	individual

The Baubiologische Institut Rosenheim (Ger­many) graded the various heating systems based on the criteria discussed above and came up with the following results:

Forced air/fuel oil 7 points

Hot water in floor/fuel oil 19 points

Wood-fired iron stove 21 points

Kachelofen-Masonry Heater 66 points

The masonry oven and its health, comfort, and ecological benefits are little known in North Amer­ica, where forced-air heating is the norm. If you are interested in heating your home in this time — tested manner you will need to seek out a mason trained in the art of masonry oven building and in­stallation. To find a certified mason in your vicin­ity you can refer to the member directory of The Masonry Heater Association of North America at mha-net. org.

Ernst Kiesling, an Austrian-educated structural engineer, has had a lifelong attraction to healthy living and green building methods. He has been involved with Kachelofens-Masonry Heaters for 31 years, starting out as a teacherfor the profession at a vocational school in Austria and then going into business building individually designed Kache­lofens-Masonry Heaters. After immigrating to Nova Scotia, Canada, he started Kiesling Construc­tion Ltd. to bring the goodness of the Kachelofen — Masonry Heaterto Canada. He can be contacted at Canadian Kachelofen, ermared@ns. sympatico. ca.

exhaust goes up the chimney. Most countries in northern Europe have developed this type of heating to perfection and masonry ovens are common there. There are many masons in the US trained in the art of masonry oven building. The Masonry Heater Association of North America has an informative website that lists trained and certified heater masons by location.